World Immigration News

Modi and Trump are on the same page on immigration

Release Date
2025-03-28
Media
ALJAZEERA
Summary
In February 2023, shocking images of undocumented Indian migrants being deported from the U.S. in chains sparked outrage in India. Opposition leaders, including Rahul Gandhi, protested the inhumane treatment, calling on Prime Minister Narendra Modi to address the issue with U.S. President Donald Trump. However, Modi responded meekly, aligning with Trump's stance on immigration, stating that India was prepared to bring back "illegal migrants" and framing many of them as victims of human trafficking.

This response reflects Modi's desire to avoid a confrontation with Trump, especially amidst ongoing trade negotiations. It also highlights the shared views between Modi and Trump on immigration. In India, the ruling BJP has promoted the narrative of an immigration crisis, particularly from Bangladesh, using unfounded claims to stoke fears about demographic changes and Muslim migration. This rhetoric has been used to justify anti-immigrant policies, such as the controversial Citizenship Amendment Act of 2019.

Undocumented Indian migrants in the U.S. symbolize broader economic issues in India, where inequality and poverty persist. Despite the government's image of a rising economic powerhouse, the reality for many is marked by extreme poverty, with India having a large share of the global increase in poverty. Modi’s approach to immigration shows his willingness to prioritize diplomatic relations with Trump over defending the rights of undocumented Indian citizens, reflecting the broader anti-immigration sentiment in both countries.
Tags
INDIA